We are family owned and operated since 1972 making us Chesterton’s oldest pizzeria. We make pizzas with your choice of thin, thick, corn meal, wheat, or deep pan crusts and offer 25 different toppings to put on them. Our dining room is decorated with large Lake Michigan photos, driftwood, and beach stones and weather permitting we have outdoor seating on our “deck under the trees”. We are located near historic downtown Chesterton.
Staymaker is a full service restaurant offering a high level of service, scratch cooking and a unique environment connected to Journeyman Distillery. Menu includes Journeyman cocktails, an array of apps, soups & salads, detroit style pizza, burgers and sandwiches.
A wood-fired brick oven turns a 1949 Studebaker fire truck into a gourmet pizza wagon. Chosen by Food Network Magazine as the Best Pizza in Indiana! We prepare thin 10″ flatbread pizzas, made to order and baked in our wood-fired oven until crisp and charred. The 900 degree oven can cook a freshly made pizza in under two minutes. We use the freshest toppings available from local farm markets, local foragers and from our garden.
Dig the Dunes Discount: One FREE topping with any pizza. Please print out this ad.